Friday, November 02, 2007

Plagiarism or inspiration?!

What's the difference between plagiarism and inspiration in the world of films? I think Nayagan is an inspiration from Godfather while Vetri Vizha is an attempt of plagiarism! Here's a list of LESSER KNOWN tamil movies and the corresponding English movies from which they have been copied/inspired. I trust your skills of discretion to come to a conclusion.

Whistle - Urban legends.
Manasukkul Matthappu - One flew over the Cuckoo's nest.
Naalaiya Manidhan -Bride of Frankenstein.
Moodu Pani -Psycho.
Julie Ganapathy -Misery.
Vaa Arugil vaa -Child's Play.
Kuzhandhaiyum Deivamum- The Parent Trap.
Makkal En Pakkam - Rage of the Angels (Sheldon's book).
Time - While you were sleeping.
SooraSamharam -Witness.
Ghajini -Memento.
Vetri Vizha -Bourne Identity.
Mazhalai pattaalam-Yours,mine and ours.
MayaBazaar(95)- Ghost.

And here's de welcome addition from Mr. Connoisseur:
Pachai kili muthu charam - Derailed
Shanthi Nilayam - Sound Of Music
Vegam -Cellular
Panchathandiram-Very bad things
My dear maarthaandan-Coming to America
Magalir mattum - 9 to 5.
Anbe sivam - planes, trains & automobiles
Avvai sanmugi - Mrs. Doubtfire
Nammavar-Lean On Me
Tenali - Patch Adams
Vettayadu vilayadu-Red Dragon
Arunachalam- Brewster's Millions
Whistle-I know what you did last summer
Rishi has the climax from Nick in Time
Vaaranam aayiram-Character
Asuran-Predator
The Life of David Gale story is similar to Virumandi
Ayirathil oruvan - Captain Blood



Well, if you don't remember Manasukkul Matthaappu,it's the Prabhu,Saranya and Sarath Babu flick set in a mental asylum where they electrocute Prabhu.
Naalaiya manidhan and Adhisaya Manidhan are movies similar to 'The Bride of Frankenstein'- the former has Ajay Ratnam transformed into an inhuman form after death; the latter has Gautami being chased around by the ghost or whatever you call it.
Makkal en pakkam-remember the Ambika,Satyaraj,Rajesh starrer where Ambika plays a lawyer, Satyaraj-a gangster and Rajesh as a corrupt politician...
Soorasamharam has Kamal Haasan and Nirosha in the lead.

7 comments:

ViJaY said...

interesting facts... I have never seen any of those english films but heard tht Ghajini is inspired/copied from memento... Will try to take a look at some of those english ones and see whether they do luk similar wid the tamil stuff...

deepa said...

sure!!! n add to de list if u can!

Sundar said...

Oh good facts...

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

Pachai kili muthu charam - Derailed
Shanthi Nilayam - Sound Of Music
Vegam -Cellular
Panchathandiram-Very bad things
My dear maarthaandan-Coming to America
Magalir mattum - 9 to 5.
Anbe sivam - planes, trains & automobiles
Avvai sanmugi - Mrs. Doubtfire
Nammavar-Lean On Me
Tenali - Patch Adams
Vettayadu vilayadu-Red Dragon
Arunachalam- Brewster's Millions
Whistle-I know what you did last summer
Rishi has the climax from Nick in Time
Vaaranam aayiram-Character
Asuran-Predator
The Life of David Gale story is similar to Virumandi
Ayirathil oruvan - Captain Blood


Nadodi Mannan and Uthama Puthiran owes it to Alexander Dumas books(Man in the Iron Mask)and a complete spoof of all that combined was Immsai Arasan

There are many more,I do not maintain a list...
These are the Hindi Version of a few i know
Judwa - Double Dragons
Baadshah -Nick in time and Rush Hour

N.B:I do not wanna pull vijay into this as it comes under remake and nothing to do with inspiration or plagirism :-) nor Vijayakanth who remakes with inspiration from Tom and Jerry

deepa said...

wow!!!! right person, right question... i'll add ur list to mine!

deepa said...

n captain padam.. aiyo paavame!!! :)